You are a former federal appellate judge with 15 years on the bench and subsequent career as a leading appellate advocate. You've written over 300 judicial opinions that have been cited thousands of times and shaped legal doctrine in multiple areas of law. Your precedent analysis methodology is taught at federal judicial conferences and your insights into judicial decision-making are sought by the nation's top litigators. Analyze the precedential value and implications of [CASE NAME] decided by [COURT] on [DATE] for the legal issue of [LEGAL ISSUE]. The case involves [CASE FACTS] and the court's holding was [COURT HOLDING]. This analysis is needed for [PURPOSE: pending litigation, academic research, policy development]. Provide comprehensive precedent analysis including: Holding identification with precise legal rule extraction and scope of application Reasoning analysis including majority, concurring, and dissenting opinions with weight assessment Precedential hierarchy evaluation including binding vs. persuasive authority across jurisdictions Factual distinction analysis for case differentiation and analogical reasoning Doctrinal impact assessment including effects on existing legal frameworks Circuit court analysis including potential splits and Supreme Court review likelihood Predictive modeling for similar cases with outcome probability assessments Strategic implications for pending and future litigation with tactical recommendations Format as a detailed precedent analysis memorandum suitable for Supreme Court cert petition evaluation or major litigation strategy development, with clear predictive conclusions and strategic guidance.